Login
support@employerschoicescreening.com
800.424.7011

Get a Quote

Employers Choice ScreeningEmployers Choice Screening
Employers Choice Screening
Employment Background Checks & Background Screening
  • About
    • Contact Us
    • FAQ
    • Certifications and Registrations
    • Testimonials
    • Giving Back
    • Our Process
      • Compliance
      • Customer Service
      • Speed & Efficiency
      • Technology
    • Division
    • Partners
      • Association Partners
      • Industry Partners
      • Strategic Partners
    • Privacy and Security
      • Privacy Statement
      • Disclaimer
      • Disaster Recovery Plan
    • ISO 9001:2015 Certified
    • Accessibility Statement
  • Background Screening
    • Screening Software
      • Applicant Tracking System
      • Online Background Screening Software
    • Employment Screening
      • Credit History Record Search
      • On-site Civil History Record Search Search
      • On-site Criminal History Record Search
      • Driving History Record Search
      • Credential and Education Verification
      • Pre-Employment Physical Examination
      • Employment History Verification
      • Federal Civil History Record Search
      • Federal Criminal History Record Search
      • Military Verification
      • Reference Verification
      • Sex Offender Registry Search
      • Social Security Number Trace
      • Social Security Number Verification
      • Workers’ Compensation Search
    • Request for Information (RFP/RFQ/RFI)
    • Health Screening
    • Pre-Employment Drug Screening
      • Hair Follicle Drug Testing
    • Form I-9 Verification
      • Form I-9 E-Verify
    • Pre-Employment Assessment Testing
    • Vendor Checklist
    • Tenant Screening
      • Civil On-site History Record Search
      • Credit History Record Search
      • On-site Criminal History Record Search
      • Driving History Record Search
      • Employment History Verification
      • Sex Offender Registry Search
      • Social Security Number Trace
    • Nanny Screening
    • Quote Request
  • Industries
    • Education
    • Financial Services
    • Healthcare
    • Nonprofit
    • Real Estate & Field Services
    • Retail
    • Staffing
    • Technology
    • Transportation
    • Utilities
    • Volunteer
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Legal Alerts
    • Tip of the Month
    • Newsletter
      • Newsletter Archive
    • Press Releases
    • Articles
    • Resources
      • Free Downloads
      • Videos
      • Webinars
  • Get Quote
Menu back  

How Background Screening Policies Eliminate Claims of Discrimination

December 8, 2018Background ScreeningBy George Ramos

crimeIn preparation of our webinar titled, “Save Big Dollars in Legal Fees & Settlement Costs by Implementing a Criminal Background Screening Policy,” we came across a very well written and informative article titled, “You Wanna Background Check Me? Well, Be Careful Where You Look.” The authors of the article, Cindy Hanson and Kali Wilson Beyah, comment on the increase in lawsuits brought to the EEOC (U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission) in the past seven years. In 2007, there were 304 cases filed regarding employment selection procedures, compared to just 100 cases filed in 2003.

In essence, the issue stems from the fact that a high number of job applicants, the majority of which are minorities, are being disqualified from employment for either having a reportable criminal record or for having poor credit history. This information is legally reportable to employers when they request a pre-employment background check on applicants.

One reason employers may be facing additional EEOC complaints is that their background screening policy (if there is one in place) is too broad in its interpretation of “disqualifying information.” Some employers are disqualifying applicants solely due to a criminal conviction record. For example, a hypothetical company’s background screening policy could state, “Any applicant who is arrested for a crime will not be considered for employment with our organization.” This statement could be considered too vague by EEOC standards.

The article also discusses the idea that employers should perhaps consider other factors or parameters when a criminal conviction record is found before disqualifying an applicant such as if the applicant was actually convicted of the crime or if the charges were dismissed. An arrest record is much different than a conviction, which is when a judge and/or jury found the subject guilty of the crime or the subject plead guilty. One good example of why arrest records should not be reported if they do not result in a conviction is cases of mistaken identity. Occasionally, the police arrest someone and later determine they were not the actual suspect in question. Charges are not filed with the courts, but the arrest record will always exist.

Make sure that the applicant was actually convicted of the crime before making an educated employment decision. Another issue to consider is what type of crime did they commit? Was it violent or drug related? Was it a misdemeanor or felony? The majority of background screening policies state that any felony conviction reported is grounds for disqualification from employment consideration. By that rationale, would an applicant still be considered for employment if they were convicted of a misdemeanor? What if the original charge was a felony and the defendant plead down to a misdemeanor? What about a misdemeanor case that is amended to an infraction charge?

One of the most important issues for employers to consider is whether the crime is relevant to the position being sought by the applicant. For example, an employer looking to hire for a delivery driver position should be very wary of applicants with a Driving Under the Influence (DUI) conviction, but may not be as concerned with other less-relevant convictions.

Due to the current economic state and record high unemployment rate, employers everywhere are seeing their applicant pool increase exponentially. The job market has never been more competitive than it is now. As a corollary, employers need to protect themselves by implementing an effective but non-discriminatory background screening policy. Employers need to ensure that their employment background screening policies are as specific as possible, especially regarding criminal record and credit report searches.

When used as a part of a holistic approach to evaluating whether an individual meets the criteria required to fill an employment position, background checks can help an employer make better decisions. If not tailored to specific job positions and used as part of a plan designed to guard against disparate impact discrimination, background checks can lead an unwitting employer to violate federal anti-discrimination laws. In light of the EEOC’s commitment to rooting out discriminatory use of background checks, it is very important that employers give significant thought to their use of background checks and have constructed job-related justifications for the practices and criteria used.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Background ScreeningBackground Screening PolicyDiscrimination ClaimsEECO Complaints
About the author

George Ramos

Related posts
The Case Against Social Media Searches in a Socially Distanced World
August 18, 2020
Should We Re-Screen Furloughed Employees?
August 18, 2020
Florida Governor Signs Mandatory E-Verify Law
August 18, 2020
Employee Background Check Companies for Employers
July 1, 2020
Employers Face Challenges with FCRA Lawsuits on the Rise
January 29, 2020
Illinois Marijuana Law Introduces New Compliance Territory
January 29, 2020
Research Your New Hires!







    Name:

    Email:

    Phone:

    Search
    Facts
    Workplace Violence
    One out of every six crimes occurs in the workplace and homicide is the second leading cause of workplace death in the U.S.

    Education Falsification
    National Credit Verification Service reports that 25% of the MBA degrees it verifies on resumes are false.

    Statistics
    72% of shrinkage is due to employee theft.
    34% of all job applications contain lies.
    30% of small business failure is caused by employee theft.
    Live Scan

    is a technique used by law enforcement agencies & private organizations to search for any criminal activity nationwide.

    Read More>

    • “Your costs for background checks are indeed quite modest in comparison to the salary costs and potential risks. I am also quite impressed with the information you have provided regarding compliance.”

      Direct Image Sensors Company
      VP Engineer & GM
    • “Thank you so much for sending the complete file as quickly as you did. Thank you once again for all of the hard work you put into pulling this report for me; it is greatly appreciated.”

      With Kind Regards,

      Staffing Company
      Manager
    • “Thanks, good job.”

      Distribution Company
      General Manager
    • “Thanks. Great turnaround!”

      Computer Resource Company
      Human Resources Manager
    • “In any event excellent service like always.”

      Regards,

      Manufacturing Company
      Human Resources Manager
    • “Thanks for the prompt result!”

      Real Estate Company
      Accountant
    Get Help Now
    Receive immediate assistance with your background checks

      Name:

      Email:

      Message:

      International Background Searches

      Did you know that we perform background searches in over 200 countries?

      Read more
      Newsletter Sign Up
      Employers Choice Screening
      ©2019 Employers Choice Online Inc. Background Screening, All Rights Reserved
      Privacy Statement | Disclaimer | FACT Act Notice
      Information
      • FAQ
      • Background Screening Links
      • Applicant Dispute
      • Report Status
      • Green Policy
      • Contact Us
      Screening Resources
      • Videos
      • Affiliate Program
      • Live Webinars
      • Online Resource Center
      • Divisions
      Read More
      • Newsletter
      • Background Screening Blog
      • Our Process
      • Certifications and Registrations
      • Associations
      footer-logo-1footer-logo-2 footer-logo-3


      Connect With Employers Choice Screening

      This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish.AcceptReject Read More
      Privacy & Cookies Policy

      Privacy Overview

      This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
      Necessary
      Always Enabled
      Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
      Non-necessary
      Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
      SAVE & ACCEPT